Justice & Crime Report

UPDF’s Defiance of Supreme Court Ruling Raises Concerns Over Judicial Independence”


On Friday, 31st, the Supreme Court issued a landmark ruling regarding the trial of civilians in military courts. This decision followed a unanimous declaration from Chief Justice Alfonso Owiny-Dollo and six other judges, who concluded that General Court Martials lack the legal qualifications and independence necessary to conduct fair trials.

Owiny-Dollo likened military court judges to untrained surgeons, warning that short-term presidential appointments for military judges severely undermine their independence. He emphasized, “Without job security, their ability to dispense justice without fear or favour is compromised.”

The Supreme Court further ruled that military courts violate fundamental constitutional principles by denying defendants the right to appeal, which is essential to the guarantee of a fair trial. As a result, the Court ordered an immediate halt to all military trials involving civilians.

However, in a defiant statement, Colonel Chris Magezi, the Public Relations Manager in the Office of the Chief of Defence Forces, declared that the General Court Martial would continue to try Dr. Kizza Besigye, despite the Supreme Court’s ruling. In a message marked by capital letters, Magezi insisted:

“The GENERAL COURT MARTIAL will continue to try ANYONE who conspires to MURDER THE PRESIDENT, commits ARMED REBELLION against Uganda, and engages in TERRORISM against the PEOPLE OF UGANDA,” he said. “Under NO CIRCUMSTANCES will Colonel Kizza Besigye be RELEASED until he faces the FULL EXTENT of MARTIAL LAW.”

The UPDF’s blatant defiance of this ruling has sparked alarm among legal experts and civil society organizations. Many are concerned that such actions erode judicial independence and the supremacy of civilian institutions.

Critics argue that disregarding the authority of the Supreme Court sets a dangerous precedent, one that risks strengthening military influence over governance and further undermining democratic principles.


Related posts

Eron Kiiza’s Sudden Appearance at High Court Creates Uncertainty Over Legal Ruling

Barbra Zeka

Prime Suspect of Ndiga clan head murder admits responsibility, demands release of 4 co-accused

ndiwalanakiwa@gmail.com

Kabaka’s Legal Team Rejected The Plea Made By His Subjects To Access His Bank Accounts And Confidential Kingdom Documents He Signed With President Museveni.

Dean Lubowa Saava

Panic At Parliament As The Clerk Adolf Mwesige Summons An Emergency Meeting: Speaker Among Accuses VP Alupo For Spying On Her Office.

admin

Uganda: Treasury at risk.

admin

UK Court Sentences Ugandan Judge Lydia Mugambe to 6 Years for Forced Labour

Dean Lubowa Saava

Security Pressure ahead of Christmas

admin

Owinyi Dolo in Trouble after Judgement of Military Trials for Civilians.

admin

IGG Orders Interdiction of Land Registry Boss Hajji Baker Mugaino Over Corruption and Fake Land Titles

Cathy Mirembe

Inside Story Of Political Prisoners: LOP Ssenyonyi Held Secret Talks With Court Martial Boss Brig. Gen. Mugabe To Rescue Bobi Wine

Dean Lubowa Saava

Leave a Comment